In 1943, at the height of the war against Nazism, Andrei Tarkovsky, the debut director of the Soviet film Ivan’s Childhood, was twelve years old, the same age as the protagonist of his cinematic ‘poem’. He told journalists this himself, dispelling rumours that he was barely past twenty. In our part of the world, filmmakers make their debuts in their twenties; in the ussr, they are still studying. Tarkovsky studied for eight years under Mikhail Romm, the master who also taught Chukray. For his graduation project he produced a medium-length narrative film. Now, at the age of thirty, he presents his first feature at the Venice Film Festival, after a great deal of thought and meticulous preparation.

A twelve-year-old doesn’t participate in war, but can live through it. Tarkovsky remembers with great clarity what he felt as a child during a period when, to underline, the ussr was in a state of total mobilization. The twelve-year-old hero of the film, the very serious young Ivan, prematurely aged, not only lives through the war but plays an active part in it, undertaking secret and perilous missions. The Germans wiped out his whole family; he has seen massacres, pillaging and deportations with his own eyes. Those eyes cannot forget. Ivan stays with his officer friends, adamantly refusing to be sent back behind the lines to school. He is driven to take revenge on those who robbed him of his childhood.

Yet childhood persists, and nourishes the pure and light-filled dreams of the young boy at war. In them he sees his mother once more, along with a cart of freshly picked apples, the horses snuffling them, and his old playmate with whom, even after death, he runs carefree and happy along the seashore. This interplay between reality and dream, on which the entire film turns, serves as the dominant lyrical motif. And yet, one feels that it is expressed in a somewhat simplistic manner. To effectively convey what interests the artist most—that war kills spiritually, as well as physically—it would have been better to develop what, at the start of the story, strikes one as a genuine insight. That is, this child who presents himself at headquarters after completing his mission, all skin and bone with enormous eyes shining with fatigue, yet at the same time possessing the determination of an adult, and a voice that commands like that of a general. Here the portrait was true: realistic yet at the same time poetic; and it captures not only the soldier in him, but the child who, having conveyed what he needed to, drifts off to sleep, murmuring: ‘I get nervous, sometimes . . .’

Thereafter, the figuration is not as successful, and the director essentially loses his way among other characters, such as a young female soldier faced with her first experience of love: a feeling that cannot even fully come into being, just as the reality of the moment interrupts all of Ivan’s dreams. As is always the case when a film’s ‘leitmotif’ is too elementary (as with the Czechoslovak director Vláčil’s The White Dove, shown here two years ago, though a much inferior film to today’s ‘debut’), the need arises to embellish it with ornate language, with formal flourishes. Ivan’s Childhood thus ends up being fundamentally cold and decorative. Its stylistic architecture greatly pleased the philosopher Sartre; but we should not be satisfied with this type of avant-garde, even as we readily acknowledge the rejuvenating function of contemporary Soviet cinema’s ambitions and the objective significance of the rupture with traditional narratives.

From a young director, one might have expected less mastery in the use of the camera, the composition of images, soft photographic effects; but a greater impulse towards thematic innovation. Certainly, Ivan’s Childhood has left the memory of a film such as The Son of the Regiment—to keep with the subject matter—far behind; yet while watching it one has the distinct impression that the director is more concerned with creating ‘poetry’ through cinema than conveying, in all its brutal reality, the tragedy of a childhood ‘shot down’ by war. In this sense, despite his antiquated ‘prose’, the elder Gerasimov seems to us at least to have taken a more modern path.footnote1

And so, the first week of the festival has drawn to a close. It has failed to live up to expectations, with not a single film truly worthy of a major prize like the Golden Lion. We know the critics on the selection committee do not share our view: for them there are at least three or four potential ‘Lions’ and, after all, it would be unnatural if they thought otherwise. Their judgements are beyond reproach, or at any rate far more defensible, at least, than those of juries of previous years who selected certain films only to savage them in the press. Everyone is entitled to their opinion; it will be up to the audience, and before that, the jury, to determine the validity of one opinion over another.

Unfortunately, the second week also promises to be fraught with setbacks and disappointments. It seems quite certain that The Trial will not be shown, and that in its place the festival will, setting aside the affront dealt it by the producers, and in fact effectively siding with them, include the previously withdrawn Eva (which, incidentally, has been publicly criticized by the selection committee). Should this come to pass, it would be an even greater scandal than that of Vivre sa vie. Speaking of which, while there are some journalists (and, regrettably, jury members) who continue to propagate the fairytale that Godard left to deal with a personal emergency involving his wife, yesterday the following message arrived, wittily presented as an advertisement in a festival bulletin. It read, in French: ‘Dear Louis Chauvet [the Figaro critic], do not worry: we adore each other. Just as we adore cinema.’ Signed: Anna (Karina) and Jean-Luc Godard.