Only two jurisdictions, both offshore, have ever voted to leave the political Europe created under the 1957 Treaty of Rome. When Greenland left in 1985 in a row over fishing rights, taking with it half the eec’s total land mass, Commission officials reportedly feared a precedent for Eurosceptic forces, particularly Britain’s Labour Party and pasok in Greece. By the time push came to shove in the combined Euroland crises of the 2010s, however, a diminished pasok would campaign for a ‘Yes’ vote on the Troika’s punitive ‘bailout’, while in the uk, it was the Conservatives who made the running on withdrawal—some by accident, others design—against growing Labour resistance. Today, Labour is flirting with taking the country back in, with or without another referendum. In Between the Waves, journalist Tom McTague revisits the convolutions of Britain-in-Europe up to the Brexit vote a decade ago. As he points out, Leave’s victory gainsaid—at least for the moment—the verdict of the Guardian’s Hugo Young in This Blessed Plot (1998), published into the Europhile ambience of early Blairism, for whom Europe was a tryst with destiny and Britain’s natural alignment, notwithstanding the country’s insular identity and the ‘demons’ of its past.

Editor-in-chief of the originally Fabian and still pro-Labour New Statesman, McTague was born in Birmingham in 1984 and grew up in a Labour household in County Durham, north-east England. His father Martin, a lobbyist for the British Mittelstand, took him to Labour conference as a teenager to see Blair in his pomp, and was given a life peerage by Starmer in July. McTague junior started out as a trainee political reporter at the Labourist Daily Mirror, then became deputy political editor at the Conservative Daily Mail and political editor at the progressive-centrist Independent on Sunday. After it folded in 2016, he reported on the post-referendum Brexit crisis for Politico—coffee dates with Starmer, then Labour’s shadow Brexit secretary, in Portcullis House—and co-authored Betting the House, a book of reportage on the 2017 general election, in which an unexpected Corbyn surge cost Theresa May’s Conservatives their parliamentary majority. McTague joined the Atlantic, the liberal American monthly, as a staff writer in 2019, covering the sorry state of Britain and the ‘brutal’ stresses on nato. His dispatches were embellished with literary references to Lampedusa and Joseph Roth—old orders, crashing down. ‘Freedom grows when people have faith in the order of things. A little part of us all, it seems to me, needs to know that a Leviathan is out there, somewhere’, he wrote in a pandemic piece headlined ‘Will Someone Take Charge?’.

In 2023 he became political editor at UnHerd, an opinion website bankrolled by hedge-fund financier Paul Marshall, who has added the old-Tory Spectator to his portfolio and invested in gb News, a low-fi emulator of Murdoch’s Fox News. Despite these stablemates, UnHerd disavows any political line, instead professing its heterodoxy: a loose cannon, but it pulls right. McTague leaned into the Gaullist thematics of UnHerd columnist Aris Roussinos, calling—tongue-in-cheek?—for ‘a Napoleon to reinvigorate the British political order’: ‘The old oak needs cutting back to be able to grow again. Vive L’Empereur!’ He toned it down upon taking over from Jason Cowley at the ns in June last year, promising ‘a journal of ideas that can help light a new direction for this [Labour] government, and for progressive politics more generally’. In the Mandelson files released by the uk government, the Ambassador is commissioned to write a Diary piece for McTague’s first issue and seeks Downing Street’s approval. He describes McTague as ‘My/Morgan’s friend’—a reference to Starmer’s chief of staff—and ‘essentially benign towards Keir’. McTague splashed with his own access feature on the Prime Minister, ‘comfortable with power, easy with its responsibilities’, after a sleepover aboard hms Prince of Wales. He wondered aloud whether this managerial figure could hold the ring against the populist right; he hopes his successor might. Burnham, he writes, ‘believes in belief. He has found it in himself. Now he has to persuade the country.’

Between the Waves is a work of history, not commentary, but isn’t above retailing such bromides. The book offers an account of Britain’s struggle over ‘the question of Europe’, proposing to chronicle ‘the events, personalities and ideas’ that took the country into Europe in 1973 and out again in 2016. In practice, this means recounting the tortured deliberations of successive Westminster governments over ways and means to stop, join, divert, slow down and ultimately disembark from the moving train of Continental integration—‘ever closer union’, if not of peoples, as pledged at Rome, then at least of national capitalisms and regulatory bureaucracies.

What are its organizing ideas? McTague observes in Oakeshottian vein that ‘there is no arc of history, no permanent settlement—only endless struggle’. At the same time, he credits as an inspiration Rick Perlstein’s Before the Storm (2001), on Barry Goldwater’s conservative takeover of the Republican party and unsuccessful tilt at the 1964 presidential election, saying in an interview that he was amazed at ‘how the losers of [Perlstein’s] history had kind of ended up winning’: ‘I thought, wow—that is the story of the Eurosceptics’. This is the second narrative element in Between the Waves, tracing the development of rearguard British Euroscepticism from a coterie of post-war conservative intellectuals—figures such as Telegraph columnist T. E. Utley and Cambridge ultra-rightist Maurice Cowling—to a younger generation comprising the likes of Oxford historian Norman Stone and philosopher Roger Struton, and a growing network of think tankers and ‘dry’ Tory mps from the 1970s onwards. ‘What they represented was a mood’, writes McTague: the ‘poetic opposition’ to British modernity. The leading protagonist, however, is the unclubbable figure of Enoch Powell, sometime Conservative mp and petit-bourgeois outrider of hard-right reaction.

Hugo Young took his title from Richard ii; McTague raids Eliot’s ‘Little Gidding’, the last of the Four Quartets. Part I of three, ironically named ‘The end of all our exploring’, runs from the Second World War to the vote to retain eec membership in 1975. McTague frames it around a quartet of protagonists, beginning with a moment their paths crossed in wartime French North Africa, late in 1942: De Gaulle, vying for position after Eisenhower’s Realpolitik selection of a pliant Vichy Admiral as High Commissioner; financier and backroom fixer Jean Monnet, ‘Father of Europe’, there to smooth things over with the Free French; future Prime Minister Harold Macmillan, then resident minister in Algiers; and Enoch Powell, at that time a mid-ranking officer in British intelligence disrupting German supply lines in Tunisia. McTague announces that he will tell the ‘story of the battle between the ideas that these four men encapsulated’. He doesn’t really, though. Macmillan in later life was a muddle-througher, not an ideas man, and of the four, only Powell is given sustained—in fact, inordinate—coverage: he attracts more index entries than Macmillan, Wilson or Heath. Powell was ‘a bit-part player’ in Algeria, McTague concedes, but his ‘ideas about the new European order would come to define British resistance to it’.

Powell is thus accorded the privilege of kicking off the first chapter. Born in Birmingham, he was a scholarship boy and precocious classicist, a fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge, at age 22. An arch-imperialist, on his return journey from Algiers to Cairo he broke out into ‘Rule Britannia’ when the pyramids came into view. With the loss of India in 1947, disdainful of the ‘sham’ Commonwealth, he retrenched, flipping to an insistent fixation with Britain alone. In Whitehall, meanwhile, the Attlee government dismissed Monnet’s 1950 plan for a European Coal and Steel Community. ‘Britain had a hinterland beyond Europe’, McTague observes. Moreover, the complacent Labour frontbench ‘did not believe any such scheme could possibly go ahead without them’. The British were on uncertain ground, however: ‘too weak to stop the project, but too powerful to need to join.’ The Truman Administration had demanded a joint reconstruction plan for Western Europe in return for the Marshall Aid and, in 1950, Secretary of State Acheson signed off on the ecsc without informing London. Europe, McTague concludes, was ‘born with American money, under American diplomatic pressure’. The same year, Powell entered Parliament for Wolverhampton in the West Midlands—apparently ‘a watershed moment in British political history’, which is putting it strongly. If this decade of Powell’s career is remembered at all, it’s for another ‘bit-part’ role: his coordinated resignation in 1958 with Chancellor Peter Thorneycroft in proto-monetarist pique at the Macmillan Cabinet’s spending plans.