BRENT D. SHAW
Transformations of the Early Mediterranean World
The impressive physical bulk of a work of history sometimes reflects the enormity of the problem, sometimes the demand for a grand new overview, but often the simple majesty of the narrative. Whatever the cause, the writing of history has of late witnessed a discernable trend back to the big. Among these recent epic endeavours are three monumental overviews of the premodern history of the Mediterranean world. The authors of these panoramic studies have focused, above all, on the great forces shaping its history and on the meta-transformations from the ancient to post-ancient worlds of which the Middle Sea was part. All are by English-language scholars working in elite universities. Even so, there is little evidence to show that the writers of these large books directly influenced one other, or that they were aware of each other’s megaprojects as they wrote.  Peregrine Horden and Nicholas Purcell, The Corrupting Sea: A Study of Mediterranean History, Oxford 2000; Michael McCormick, Origins of the European Economy: Communications and Commerce, ad 300–900, Cambridge 2001; and Chris Wickham, Framing the Early Middle Ages: Europe and the Mediterranean, 400–800, Oxford and New York 2005 (a paperback edition was issued in 2006); for American readers at least, this work now bears the somewhat ominous acronym of fema. As the last in the series, although not by much, Wickham lists Horden and Purcell in his bibliography, but with indications of haste: one author’s name is misspelled and there is little evidence of the actual use of their work (all in the final chapter). The convergence of historical interest seems, rather, to be of a more fortuitous and meaningful kind.
Subscribe for just £45 and get free access to the archive
Please login on the left to read more or buy the article for £3
- Rodney Hilton: Feudalism in Europe: Problems for Historical Materialists
- Geoffrey de Ste. Croix: Class in Marx’s Conception of History, Ancient and Modern
- Pierre Vilar: Marxist History, a History in the Making: Towards a Dialogue with Althusser
- Georgi Derluguian, Liuba Derluguian: The Other Mediterranean
- Julian Thomas: Grand Narratives of Prehistoric Europe
- Peter Burke: Uses of the Useless Peter Burke on Françoise Waquet, Latin or the Empire of a Sign. The first comprehensive study of the role of Europe’s dead language in the culture and social structure of the modern age.
- Gopal Balakrishnan: Role of Force in History Gopal Balakrishnan takes issue with an ambitious attempt to apply evolutionary paradigms to human history, which would locate the wellsprings of conflict in the combative make-up of the species. Azar Gat’s War in Human Civilization as an instance of neo-social darwinism adapted to the multicultural spirit of the age.
- Robin Osborne: Cultures of Empire: Greece and Rome How was Roman imperial rule over Greece legitimated in the minds of conquerors and subjects alike? The mutual reverberations of an Augustan cultural revolution that brought Hellenism to the empire’s core and diverted Greeks to the glories of the past.