If you are having trouble with the NLR website, please provide details here, and we will try to improve the site accordingly.
Fred Halliday and Jon Halliday and Gareth Stedman Jones and Lucien Rey
Communication on Women’s Liberation
In discussion of the two replies to Wally Seccombe’s article on domestic labour under capitalism, it is stated in the Themes of nlr 89: ‘Jean Gardiner, writing from a “Marxist feminist” position, criticizes it, among other things, for denying “any validity in their own right to the kind of questions being raised by the feminist movement”. Margaret Coulson, Branka Magaš and Hilary Wainwright, on the other hand, stress the need to base any scientific analysis of domestic labour on the dual role of women as wage-earners and housewives and draw out the implications of such an analysis for the strategic unity of women’s liberation and the proletarian class struggle.’ Without going into the substance of this debate, we think the Themes has summarized the point at issue in an inaccurate and misleading way. Firstly, we fail to understand the reason why a Marxist feminist position is qualified as a ‘Marxist feminist’ position. Marxist feminism represents, not only a discernible, but an important and fruitful theoretical and political current within the women’s and proletarian movements. Secondly, a Marxist feminist position is not simply concerned to affirm the validity of ‘the questions being raised by the feminist movement’. It is concerned to criticize and extend Marxism itself from historical materialist premisses, in particular through an analysis of the connections between the capitalist mode of production and the sexual division of labour. It is, therefore, equally concerned to provide a ‘scientific analysis’ which would lay the basis for ‘the strategic unity of women’s liberation and the proletarian class struggle’. In so far as the Themes, intentionally or unintentionally, lends support to the misunderstandings we have mentioned, we would like to dissociate ourselves from the position put forward there.
Subscribe for just £35 and get free access to the archive
Please login on the left to read more or buy the article for £3
- Margaret Coulson, Branka Magas, Hilary Wainwright: 'The Housewife and her Labour under Capitalism'--A Critique
- Jean Gardiner: Women's Domestic Labour
- Maxine Molyneux: Beyond the Domestic Labour Debate
- Wally Seccombe: The Housewife and Her Labour Under Capitalism
- Wally Seccombe: Domestic Labour: Reply to Critics